Lindsay Shiver, a 38-year-old mom of three from Georgia, used to be a beauty queen and cheerleader.
She was married to Robert Shiver, a former Auburn football player, and they had a picture-perfect life, with a big house, fancy vacations, and the works.
But behind the scenes, their 13-year marriage was falling apart. By 2023, they were in a nasty divorce, fighting over their kids and a $2.5 million home.
Things took a dark turn in the Bahamas, where the couple owned a second home. Lindsay was allegedly seeing a local bartender, Terrance Bethel.
Then, in July 2023, police stumbled across some jaw-dropping evidence while investigating a bar break-in.
They found WhatsApp messages that suggested Lindsay, Bethel, and a guy named Faron Newbold Jr.were plotting to kill Robert!
The Alleged Murder for Hire Plot
Here’s what the cops say went down:
- The Evidence: WhatsApp messages where Lindsay allegedly sent Newbold a photo of Robert with the words “kill him.”
- The Drama: Bethel was mad after Robert and Lindsay had a big fight. One message from Bethel said Robert got physical with Lindsay and blocked her from using their private jet.
- The Claim: Prosecutors say these messages prove a murder plot. Lindsay and Bethel insist it’s all a big misunderstanding.
The trio’s charged with conspiracy to commit murder, facing up to 60 years if convicted.
They’ve all pleaded not guilty, and the case is still unfolding.
What’s Happening with the Trial?
The trial’s been a wild ride, with more delays than a canceled flight. Here’s a quick look at the key moments:
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| July 2023 | Lindsay, Bethel, and Newbold arrested in Abaco, Bahamas. |
| August 2023 | Released on bail: Lindsay ($100,000), Bethel and Newbold ($20,000 each). |
| December 2023 | Lindsay allowed to visit family in Alabama for Christmas, with restrictions. |
| October 2024 | Bail revoked after Lindsay and Bethel’s TV interviews (Good Morning America, Inside Edition). Sent to Fox Hill Prison. |
| February 2025 | Bail reinstated; Lindsay returns to Alabama under strict conditions. |
Right now, Lindsay’s back in Alabama, living with her parents and dealing with divorce drama while waiting for the trial.
Who’s Involved in This Mess?
Let’s break down the key players:
- Lindsay Shiver: Former beauty queen, accused of masterminding the plot.
- Robert Shiver: The target, now 39, who previously dated reality star Savannah Chrisley but split from her in March 2025.
- Terrance Bethel: Lindsay’s alleged boyfriend, a Bahamas bartender who says he’s innocent.
- Faron Newbold Jr.: The supposed hitman, also out on bail and denying the charges.
Oh, and there’s more. After moving back to the U.S., Lindsay started dating a guy named Dorsey Ryan Love.
That went south fast. He was arrested in July 2024 for allegedly attacking her. Trouble seems to follow her.
Why’s This Case Such a Big Deal?
Source: Fox News
This story’s got everyone glued to their screens. It’s like a soap opera with high-stakes wealth, betrayal, and a sunny island backdrop.
Media outlets like Court TV, People Magazine, and NewsNation are eating it up.
Things got heated when Lindsay and Bethel went on Good Morning Americaand Inside Edition in October 2024, claiming they were innocent.
The judge wasn’t having it, saying those interviews could mess with the trial. That’s what landed them back in jail for a bit. Social media’s buzzing too; folks can’t get enough of the drama.
What’s Next for the Trial?
The trial has been delayed yet again and is now set for March 2, 2026, in Nassau.
This marks the fourth postponement of the proceedings – the August 29, 2025 date was pushed back just days before this article was written.
The Bahamas court system moves at its own pace, and given the pattern of delays, even this new date isn’t guaranteed.
The Bottom Line
The Lindsay Shiver case shows how quickly a perfect life can fall apart. What started as a messy divorce turned into serious criminal charges that could change three lives forever.
The WhatsApp messages at the heart of this case will decide if this was really a murder plot or just angry words between upset people.
This story matters because it reminds us that money and status don’t protect anyone from making bad choices. Real people are affected – three kids caught in the middle, families torn apart, and reputations destroyed.
As the August 2025 trial approaches, one question remains: Will justice find the truth behind all the drama? The answer will determine if Lindsay Shiver spends decades in prison or walks free.
